×

Tokyo String Quartet Passes the Acid Test

January 26 2006 Review

By Paul S. Bodine for ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER

Into the Irvine Barclay theater on Tuesday night, the Tokyo String Quartet carried with it not only the question that dogs all legendary quartets – – does it still have it? – – but the extra burden of proving it has worked through the identity crisis that tarnished its reputation in the 1990s.

The current incarnation – – Kazuhide Isomura (viola), Kikuei Ikeda (violin), Clive Greensmith, (cello), and Martin Beaver (first violin) – is less than four years old, and it’s fair to ask whether the Tokyo is still the quartet that not so long ago was anointed “world’s best” by more than a few critics.

Quartets by Haydn and Dvorak and a Mozart clarinet quintet (with Sabine Meyer) made for a respectable acid test.

Unlike quite a few other nicknamed Haydn works, the G-minor Quartet (Op. 74) is called “The Rider” (though never by Franz Joseph) for very good reason: the distinctive, almost comical “gallop” that launches the fourth movement.

This is late Haydn, a polished example of “the father of the string quartet” deciding to reinvent his brainchild before his genre was barely a quarter-century old. Dropping his earlier style of setting in play a conversation among four independent voices, Haydn began emphasizing the quartet is a “symphonic” ensemble.

This proved the perfect vehicle for the Tokyo Quartet, whose defining sound has been unity and balance rather than personality and virtuosity for their own sakes. The quartet’s unanimity of sound and rapt playing showed Haydn’s Largo to be an almost Beethovenian thing – – expressive, yearning – – miles away from the stereotyped “Papa Haydn,” the musical jokester.

The Tokyo four also made Dvorak’s over-programmed “American” Quartet in F major (Op. 96) sound fresh, even profound. Its taut (but never pressed), transparent (but not sterile) playing stair Dvorak’s first three movements clear of the sentimental, folksy reading they sometimes receive. The Tokyo Quartet boasted not only staggering dynamic control but a complete mastery of the piece’s emotional pacing. Climaxes were unforced but intense, the quartet’s clean, burnished tone never seemed thick or overluxurious, ensemble was flawless, and rough edges were not to be heard.

The program closed with Mozart’s Clarinet Quintet in A major (K. 581) with virtuoso Sabine Meyer making her Orange County debut (surprising given that her career is well into its third decade). Some may remember Meyer as the first woman to break up the all-male club that was once the Berlin Philharmonic. Though that orchestra eventually voted her out for “musical” reasons, Meyer got the last laugh by fashioning an illustrious solo career that has helped resuscitate the clarinet as a concerto instrument.

From her first notes – – big, warm, golden – – Meyer captured the almost vocalistic singing line that runs throughout Mozart’s late masterpiece. For the next half-hour, she and Tokyo Quartet settled into a relaxed, mutually admiring, seemingly effortless virtuosity that earned a hale of bravos at its close.

A standing ovation prompted the jocular Menuetto from Weber’s Clarinet Quintet (Op. 34) as encore. Both the Tokyo Quartet and Meyer passed the acid test.

 

Copyright: Paul S. Bodine; TightLikeThis.com. All rights reserved.

Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com