×

Three by Three Shine

November 4 2006 Review

By Paul S. Bodine for ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER

The Bronfman-Shaham-Harrell Piano Trio didn’t exist three weeks ago, but you wouldn’t have guessed it from their performance of music by Mozart, Shostakovich, and Schubert on Thursday night at the Irvine Barclay Theater (sponsored by the Philharmonic Society of Orange County).

Originally christened and the Bronfman-Shaham-Mørk Trio, the trio lost their phenom cellist Truls Mørk before this current nine-city tour even started when his father’s illness summoned him back to Norway. Fortunately, veteran cellist Lynn Harrell, something of a phenom himself, stepped in to keep the tour alive. This was never going to be a case of a lesser or less-known musician trying to fill larger shoes.

Though all three of these artists are capable of filling halls for recitals or concertos on their own, this is no guarantee of their ability to synergize, especially in such last-minute circumstances. The concert’s first piece, Mozart’s Piano Trio in C Major (K. 548), was there for a test, one Yefim

Bronfman, Gil Shaham and Harrell easily passed: they can play together.

The 1788 work is one of three in which Mozart enabled for piano trio to finally come into its own as a genre. For the first time the violin and cello were given more independent rules relative to the once-dominant piano, and rather than using the cello merely to support the bass line, Mozart gave it its own voice.

Repetitive in structure in not especially profound, the work is nevertheless pure Mozart, with an exquisite middle movement that allowed Harrell, overshadowed by Shaham’s prominent violin part in the first movement, to show his warm and expressive tone. With Bronfman playing with classical restraint and Harrell hemmed in by the cello’s still limited role, Shaham drove the work with the fluid, piercing sound of his 1699 “Countess Polignac” Stradivarius.

Shostakovich’s Piano Trio No. 2 in E minor was written in circumstances – – in war-ruined Russia after the composer had learned of a friend’s death in a Nazi concentration camp—difficult for most of us to imagine. Yet such is its hair-raising power that by its closing bars, Shostakovich’s hell seems all too real. From the eerie discord of the opening andante to the violent plucking and brutal chording of the second movement, Bronfman, Shaham and Harrell let us deftly down into the musical equivalent of a psychological prison whose inmate rages madly against his own despair. Though the third movement was not as grotesquely comic as the Kalichstein-Laredo-Robinson’s reading at this same venue last November, the emotional impact was at least as great – – so intense that a piano tuner spent the intermission tweaking Bronfman’s Steinway back into playable form.

What can follow Shostakovich and not seem anticlimatic? Only genius, and Schubert’s Piano Trio No. 2 in E-flat Major serves up plenty of that. The fascinating piano writing in the opening allegro finally allowed Bronfman to show his chops, and Harrell’s playing was a highlight of the second movement’s sublime “processional.” Robert Schumann described this piece as “like some angry portent in the sky,” but in Bronfman, Shaham, and Harrell’s hands it was all charm, light, and inspiration.

 

Copyright: Paul S. Bodine; TightLikeThis.com. All rights reserved.

Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com