By Paul S Bodine for ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER
“Is there a viola player in the house?” Broken strings are an occupational hazard for chamber musicians, and they occur frequently enough in concert that few players let them throw them off their game. But what do you do if you didn’t bring a spare?
When that predicament confronted by violist Aleksey Koptev early in the St. Petersburg String Quartet’s Sunday concert at Saddleback College, the house lights went up after a lengthy delay, and the McKinney Theater audience was importuned to save the day. The lone violist in the crowd had unfortunately come without his catgut, but a new string was eventually found, leaving Koptev and company with a mountain-size test of their professional composure.
Though the mishap occurred only three minutes into the second movement of Ravel’s String Quartet, the Russians had already shown their colors: vivid, rhythmically energetic, playing with dead-on centered tone, a distaste for sentimentality and cloying interpretations, and a blended sound that emphasized unison rather than instrumental “argument.” This approach suited their program perfectly — pieces by a Frenchman, a Czech, and a Russian that take liberties with the Germanic “four equal voices in conversation” model for quartet writing of Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven.
In all the three works there is the sense that sheer melodiousness or musical effect matter far more than some convention of structural cohesion. In choosing them, the St. Petersburgers stood the standard quartet program — Haydn/Mozart, Romantic crowd pleaser, Beethoven — pretty much on its ear. The concert opened with the most complex, modern and arguably important papers reveals only string Quartet the concert opened with the most complex, modern and arguably important piece, Ravel’s only string quartet, followed by Dvorak’s “American” Quartet (a tuneful Romantic piece, to be sure), and then culminated with the seldom-played first quartet of Borodin, a composer unaccustomed to such marquee status.
It was, in other words, an afternoon for the unexpected. In the remaining movements of the Ravel, the St. Petersburgers seemed to be finding their way back into the work, and a certain looseness or lack of impetus prevailed. Highlighted by first violinist Alia Aranovskaya’s consistently expressive playing and singing tone, however, the Russians regained their poise and urgency in the last movement. Except in the Dvorak quartet’s very closing pages, the St. Petersburgers deemphasized the work’s nostalgic sunniness for a more intense sound and slower tempos. This was not the adopted “American” composer reinventing plantation spirituals while summering in Iowa, but something darker and more interesting.
Borodin probably intended a tribute to Beethoven in subtitling his always intriguing first Quartet, “after a theme by Beethoven,” but, like the Ravel and Dvorak, it was sheer tunefulness, rather than Beethoven-like emotional anguish and complex contrapuntal structure that caught the ear. The quartet’s confident dispatch of the piece’s fugatos, the third movement’s weird harmonics, and the finale’s vigorously strutting main theme proved that they had put the opening mishap behind them.
The well-earned encore was an effortlessly executed Jewish folk dance that showed off the Russians’ considerable chops. Despite the opening-night glitches, the appearance of a quartet of St. Petersburg’s stature augurs well for this year’s Saddleback International Guest Artist Series, which also features classical guitarist Paul Galbraith (Oct. 10), the Jacques Thibaud String Trio from Berlin (March 13) and Quartet San Francisco (May 13).
Copyright: Paul S. Bodine; TightLikeThis.com. All rights reserved.