Paul Bodine for San Francisco Classical Voice
“Carmina Burana? Again?” Anyone posing that fair question going into Pacific Chorale’s season-opening concert on Saturday, October 17, at Segerstrom Concert Hall (Costa Mesa) probably left humming one of its indelible tunes. Yes, Carl Orff’s 1937 setting of medieval Latin and vernacular poems relishes its own primitivism, can be repetitious to a fault, was adopted by the Nazis, and is programmed more than it probably should be. But its status as perhaps the world’s most programmed cantata is no fluke. Its musical simplicity (elemental harmonies, homophony, repetition), percussive drive, attractive melodies, no-dawdle pace, and emotional directness retain their power. Even Orff, then 41, recognized what he’d wrought: “Everything I have written to date … can be destroyed. With Carmina Burana my collected works begin.”
But Pacific Chorale’s Carmina Burana was doubly special. It was the Orange County premiere of Paul Leonhard Schäffer’s 2022 arrangement of Carmina for chamber orchestra, played here by 36 musicians. By substantially reducing the forces stipulated in Orff’s score, percussion included, Schäffer shifts the spotlight firmly onto the singers.
Approaching its 60th anniversary, Pacific Chorale has built its now international reputation through adventurous programming exactly like this, including dozens of premieres and commissions. Its Carmina was rendered with impeccable ensemble, vocal sheen and weight, superb layering, and personality when it mattered.
Robert Istad (pictured below left), in his 10th year as John Alexander’s successor, led the Chorale and a pared-down (but plenty sonorous) Pacific Symphony with precision and undemonstrative authority. Key instrumental contributions came from Pam Martchev (flute and piccolo), Barry Perkins (trumpet), Keith Popejoy and Sarah Bach (French horn), and Robert Slack, Will Howald, and Danielle Squyres (percussion). As if the Chorale needed reinforcements, Lori Loftus’s Southern California Children’s Chorus — 27 teens (including three boys) — injected buoyant charm into two movements in the “Cour d’amours” (Court of love) section.

Among the three soloists, baritone Michael Kelly (pictured above right), gamely traversing roles as varied as pining lover, drunken abbot, and debauched sinner, carried the day with powerful vocalism. Lyric soprano Anna Schubert, who also sang the solo part in Starr Parodi’s ‘I Am America’ before the intermission, brought a serene presence and crystalline voice to her progression from wistful longing to erotic surrender. Decked out in a black tux, white wings on each shoulder, and two-tone wingtips, lyric tenor JJ Lopez (pictured below) nearly stole the show as the slow-rotisseried swan in “Olim lacus colueram.”

This Pacific Chorale concert was also special for what preceded it — two pieces that offset Carmina’s pagan world of luck, love, and wine by invoking nobler themes. Commissioned by Pacific Chorale, the opening world premiere, I Am America, was composed (music and text) by Parodi, recognizable to those of a certain age as a keyboardist in the house band on The Arsenio Hall Show but now a versatile composer for film, television, and concert hall.
Thoughtfully conceived and warmly intended, I Am America is built around a semiquincentennial text that sidesteps our fraught, polarized moment by letting America, the place and the idea, do the talking. Daring to speak of “a hopeful journey,” it spins textual variations on the theme of America as “brave thought becoming the dream of freedom.” Musically, I Am America moves from passages of extraordinary massed choral power to moments of rapt, almost spiritual grandeur, before closing in a more martial or “popular patriotic” mode. Parodi’s assured handling of the chorus and her tastefully understated brass, woodwind, and string writing gave the Chorale and soloist Schubert all they needed to put this inspirational work across.

The first half concluded with the North American premiere of Tarik O’Regan’s remarkable Critical Mass, whose motivating ideal is not national unity (as with Parodi) but spiritual remaking. Building a larger Mass around his existing Agnus Dei, composed for King Charles III’s 2023 coronation, O’Regan (pictured below center) set four newly commissioned movements based on liturgically inspired texts he solicited from English stage director John Caird, Irish novelist Colm Tóibín, Orange County poet and artist Marcus Omari (pictured below left), and American poet and Anglican priest Alice Goodman. To these, he added his own closing “Go” — a riff on the Mass’s dismissal, “Ite, missa est” — in which he reinforces the re-creation theme.

Using only strings, percussion, and harp, O’Regan eschewed sacred-music conventions to simply respond to the texts his authors wrote (with only minimal guidance from him). In “Creator, absolve us,” for example, O’Regan uses tenebrous string and percussion effects to build slowly from an initial repentant hush to the intense movement’s surging, then fading, climax. And “Gloria to the low grey sky” rides an insistent pulse through recurring waves of the Chorale’s high-register invocations of the “forgiving light” Tóibín sees in Veronese’s painting of the Annunciation.
Critical Mass is an arresting work of expressive power; Pacific Chorale delivered it with polish and conviction.
Photo credits: Pacific Chorale