×

An Interview with Herbert Blomstedt

April 9 2025 Blog Post

As Herbert Blomstedt approaches his 98th year—still leading orchestras—I recall an interview I did with him on February 10, 2004, before his February 21 performance with the Royal Concertgebouw in Costa Mesa, California. The article I submitted to the Orange County Register (published on February 18) was abridged by editors, so only a fragment of Blomstedt’s words made it into print (now published on this blog). I share the full interview below.

 

From 1998 to 2005 (the year after this interview), Blomstedt was the Gewandhauskapellmeister of Leipzig’s legendary Gewandhausorchester, a role previously held by Kurt Masur and now held by Andris Nelsons. Blomstedt first conducted the Royal Concertgebouw in the 1983-84 season, but built his career leading orchestras as diverse as the San Francisco Orchestra, Dresden’s Staatskapelle, Bamberg Symphony, Danish National Symphony Orchestra, NHK Symphony, and Swedish Radio Symphony. Though raised in Sweden, Blomstedt was born in Springfield, Massachusetts in 1927.

 

PB: I started the call by more or less thanking him for his 1988 recording of Carl Nielsen’s Fifth Symphony with San Francisco Symphony, still arguably the best interpretation of this important twentieth-century symphony.

HB: It’s a wonderful piece, isn’t it?

PB: I asked him about his Concertgebouw tour and schedule.

HB: Oh yes, the whole two seasons after that are already full. Yes, I’ll be touring lots of guest conducting. I have so many friends everywhere in the world, orchestras that I have been leading. I have more time for them. I had very little time for them during the past seven years in the Gewandhaus. That’s such a big job. [chuckles]

 

PB: I asked him about German reunification’s effect on the Leipzig Gewandhaus audience. Did it negatively or positively affect ticket sales?

HB: No, that was only after the first year or so. Ticket sales at Gewandhaus have never been higher. Ticket sales have been at an all-time high. Ticket sales increased at every orchestra I’ve directed – Dresden [where he was music director from 1975 to 1985], Leipzig, San Francisco [music director from 1985 to 1995]. Always full, always full, no decline. The audiences are wonderful here [Leipzig].

 

PB: I asked about being credited with giving the San Francisco Symphony a distinctive sound. How do you give an orchestra distinctive sound if it doesn’t have one?

HB: Oh, that sounds like a very good question. Actually, I cannot answer it because that’s not my goal, to put on a distinctive sound [laughs]. That’s not what I’m going for at all. The sound that comes out is the result of the personality of the orchestra and the personality of a conductor. It’s like a marriage, you know. The children that come out will be a mixture that is quite different from time to time. And if it’s a good match, it can be some very good children. My aim is to make just as expressive and beautiful music as close to the intention of the composer as I possibly can. I come to any orchestra with special ideas, with special character traits that are typical of myself and sometimes that makes good with what the orchestra needs and what they want and what they are. And then some extraordinary results can come out. I think the process is just as simple as that, and also as undescribable and unanalyzable [laughs].

 

PB: I asked about the possibility of individual orchestras’ distinct sound becoming more homogenized.

HB: I think [that arises all right]. [That] is a real question and a serious one. That is, I think the result of the intense communications that we have today with radio and recordings, and so on [that] we, people, listen a lot to recordings, radio, compare, are influenced by the sound, And it’s just as the TV culture of today. So many people have their only information from TV and that forms their world, their character and their viewpoints, and their ideals. And it tends then to be more unified than it was earlier centuries when people lived more secluded in their own valleys and on cities, probably their whole life, and developed more distinctive characteristics that were kept from generation to generation. I think this has something good with it, of course, this intense communication. We are grateful for it, but when it threatens the individuality of people or individuals or orchestras, artists, I think it is dangerous. One has to remain individuals, and I think the only way of solving that is to remain at the source. That is, for us musicians, to remain close to the text, the scores, and not to listen to what this or this says, and this and this says, not what this critic means and this critic means, or my teachers on this or that, but to listen to what the score says. Then, since every individual is different, one will arrive anyhow at different results. And I think that is a very important process, and when also the public goes to hear a concert, they have a right to hear Beethoven and Brahms and Bruckner, Stravinsky, whatever it is, unadorned, so to speak, by the idiosyncrasies of the interpreter.  But still, it must be very personal, otherwise the music has no message, and this I think is important. We must allow ourselves to be original and personal.

 

PB: I asked about the musician’s or the orchestra’s mission.

HB: Yes, I think we have a mission. Our big mission, of course, is to bring good music to the public. And that’s a very broad concept, and to make the public as broad as possible, as big as possible, ideally comprising, everybody [laughs] in society. But since there are many who bring the same sort of repertoire, which is also good, because there is a classical repertoire, there is a sort of special canon of the greatest works. But there are lots of minor lights and minor planets and stars that also have a claim to our attention. And here is where the special mission of every individual musician comes in. Since we cannot play everything, we have to make choices.

 

PB: I asked about the factors that cause a conductor, Blomstedt, to choose the ‘lesser lights’ such as Carl Nielsen.

HB: Personal favorites, friendships with composers, trying to help these composers. I knew Nielsen’s music, of course, because he was Danish, but was quite appalled at how little he was known in Germany, even today. It’s a little better in the UK today and in Central Europe. It’s like sitting on an enormous treasure chest: you just have to show what’s under[neath] to the world.

 

PB: I asked about his association with the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra. What makes them unique?

HB:  I’ve been associated with them on and off quite often for 15–20 years. It has to do with their tradition. It’s not one of the oldest orchestras like the Gewandhaus Orchestra, for instance, which is the oldest philharmonic in the world [founded in 1743], about 250 years old and more. Or the Dresden Staatskapelle, which is the one of the oldest opera orchestras in the world, 450 years old [founded 1548]. The Concertgebouw Orchestra is about 100, I would guess, I don’t have the exact figures, I would guess 125 years old or something like that [it first performed in 1888]. It’s a relatively young orchestra, but one of the greatest. It was shaped by Willem Mengelberg [1871-1951], during a very long tenure, and he was a formidable orchestra trainer and a great personality, and he formed his orchestra [with a] very personal, subjective approach to music. The orchestra’s musicians went all the way with him. It’s a spontaneous orchestra, very giving, very thoughtful, but above all extremely musical and sensitive. They get carried away with the music in a very special way.

PB: I asked him if it’s possible to be a great orchestra in a bad halls.

HB: Tricky question. Generally no, but there are many examples that belie that. For instance, the Philadelphia Orchestra till recently played in a hall most of us think was very inferior [Academic of Music]. Dry acoustic, dry theater acoustics. But it was a great orchestra! And they were not put down by that. On the contrary, they used the inferiority of the hall, the dryness of the acoustic, they learned to cope with it through playing in an extreme, colorful way, and with a very mellow and rich way that compensated the dry acoustic. And today the Philadelphia Orchestra is very much a product of that kind of acoustics, and many people in Philadelphia I know we’re very attached to that hall. And there was a big outcry when that hall should be abandoned and a new one [Kimmel Center for the Performing Arts, opened 2001] built. I will play in the new hall in a couple of days [laughing], Friday, for the first time, so I’ll get to know it myself. But I suspect that that is a very much better hall.

 

PB:  I asked about Disney Hall’s acoustics in comparison with the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion.

HB:  Yes, it [Chandler, opened 1964] was a distinctly bad hall. Just as the Lincoln [Center’s] Avery Fisher Hall in New York [opened 1962] is a bad hall.  So I’m very happy for Los Angeles that they have got this [Disney Hall, opened 2003]. I’m very curious. I play there in a couple of years [January 2007, conducting the Los Angeles Philharmonic].

PB: I asked whether memorizing scores, as he favors doing, improves his performance.

HB:  Yes, definitely, otherwise I would not do it. It’s a very tiresome process. It requires intense study over many years. Every time you add a new piece to your repertoire it’s an excruciatingly tiresome process that requires enormous, much time. But nobody of course should notice that there is so much labor behind it. But the advantages, at least I feel this way, are so great that for me it’s necessary to do it with all repertoire pieces that you play more than once or twice, I would say, because it gives me much more liberty. I can hear much better what actually the orchestra is playing when I know the score very well, and I don’t have to turn pages to check this and check that with my eyes. I can be completely at the disposal of my orchestra and have close contact with anyone in the orchestra at any moment. I don’t have to look at the score. And you can only bring out from the orchestra what you actually hear in your inner ear. Otherwise, it would be a more al fresco sort of total sound that comes out. It might be quite winning and very nice, but not so full of detail and transparency, as if when you know the score so well that you don’t need to look at It.

 

PB: I asked him whether religious faith makes him a better musician. He is a devout Seventh-day Adventist, and never rehearses on Friday nights or Saturdays, the Seventh-day Adventist sabbath. He will conduct concerts, however, because he believes actual performances are no longer work, but religious expression.

HB:  That question’s a little bit too simple [laughs] because if I said unreservedly, yes to that, that would mean that if I were not religious, I would not be such a good musician, and it would mean that if others of my colleagues would improve their musicianship, they would get more religious. It’s not as simple as that. But my feeling for God, search for God, idea of God’s greatness informs who I am, me as a person, musician, puts a stamp on me as a person. I’m a seeker. I find God in many places, in nature and scores, in people. I’m not saying I’m a pantheist, not ‘god on every table’, in my big toe. As my models have not all of them been religious people in the more strict sense — they go to church, read the Bible, pray on their knees every morning — or something like that, is too simple an idea. Even if these musicians are not of that kind, they in order to become great musicians, I think, have to be seekers of truth. The truth is I think the ultimate aim of every artist. The aim is not to project himself, to show how good he is and how clever he is, but there is something in the music that he thinks is important to everyone, and that when understood by the listeners will also bring them close to an answer to these eternal questions — where we come from, and why we are here, and where we are going.

 

PB:  I asked him about his interest in Kierkegaard because he owns his complete writings.

HB:  Perhaps [I have read] not every word [laughs]. But of course, that’s the life’s work, but we read very much, Kierkegaard; he never stops to surprise me. I have, after I bought that first set of 23 volumes, I have quite a big Kierkegaard library, with the first complete editions and many of the original works in their first editions from the 1840s. I even have volumes that he signed himself. I am amazed every time I read something of him. Also, how musically was there are so close parallels to his thinking, and to the musical world. He was very sensitive to music.

PB:  I asked him about future recording projects.

HB:  [There is] Mozart’s Don Giovanni, which is a live recording from Leipzig made three months ago and another one is a huge, modern piece by Swedish composer Sven-David Sandström, the title is ‘The High Mass’ [Deutsche Grammophon, December 2004]. It’s a piece modeled on the Bach B Minor Mass without being a pastiche in any way. It’s a modern piece but the scope of the piece and the dispersion of the text corresponds to the B Minor Mass. And that’s also a recording from two live performances in Leipzig in May last year. And then we are completing a recording in next September, a Strauss recording that we will complete with the ‘Burleske’ [with Jean-Yves Thibaudet, Decca, June 2005]. Already recorded a ‘Rosenkavalier’ suite [waltzes], and — what was more on it — I think it was the ‘Four Last Songs’ [it was Strauss’s Sextet From Capriccio]. Yeah, that will be a complete Strauss recording.

PB:  I asked about Swedish composer Wilhelm Stenhammar (1871 – 1927) and Norwegian Johan Svendsen (1840 – 1911), whose music I enjoy.

HB:  I have no recording plans for those, but this is music I am certainly playing all the time. Stenhammar is a very underrated composer. Stenhammer by the way in his youth was a frequent guest of the Gewandhaus as a piano soloist. And I’m playing his big orchestra ‘Serenade’ [opus 31, 1919] on tour next year and also the year afterward on tour [Blomstedt recorded it with the Gothenburg Symphony in 2017 (BIS)]. All this recording by the way, there’s also a piece by [Henry] Litolff [1818 – 1891] that we’ll record as a filler [his ‘Concerto Symphonique No. 4’, Op. 102, recorded with the BBC Symphony Orchestra in 2008]. Wonderful piece on a Russian Orthodox hymn for big orchestra without singers.

PB:  Looking forward to hearing Concertgebouw in Costa Mesa.

HB:  That’s quite a good hall if I remember. Thank you.

 

Featured image photo credit: Priska Ketterer

Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com