×

A Twentieth-century Pillar

January 27 2026 Review

Paul Bodine for Classical Music Daily

 

Could the recent accelerating pace of Chicago Symphony Orchestra visits to Orange County, California, represent a trend? That was the hope of at least one audience member at its January 24 performance at Renée and Henry Segerstrom Concert Hall in Santa Ana, sponsored by the Philharmonic Society of Orange County.

 

Since its first appearance locally in 1965, led by music director Jean Martinon (at Melodyland Theater in Anaheim), the CSO has been an inconstant guest. A quarter century passed before Georg Solti and the Philharmonic Society of Orange County — the presenter of every CSO visit — brought them back in 1987, but another multi-year absence intervened until the opening of acoustically vibrant Segerstrom Concert Hall in 2006 seemed to spark more frequent visits. Under music director Riccardo Muti, the CSO returned in 2012, 2017, and 2023.

 

In its taut, robust performance of Johann Strauss Jr., Paul Hindemith, Igor Stravinsky, and Maurice Ravel January 24, the symphony and Philharmonic Society closed an air-tight case for making Orange County an even more regular stop. In his previous California winter tours, Muti – now CSO Music Director Emeritus for Life — has often offered uncommon programming, from Honegger’s ‘Pacific 231’ and Mason Bates’ ‘Alternative Energy’ in 2017 to Anatoly Liadov’s ‘The Enchanted Lake’ in 2023. Upping the ante this time, Muti offered two infrequently performed works–Hindemith’s magisterial ‘Mathis der Maler’ symphony (based on his three-hour opera) and Stravinsky’s four-movement ‘Le Baiser de la fée’ (The Fairy’s Kiss) suite—that were also the most substantial. These were bookended by short but sure crowd-pleasers, Strauss’s ‘The Gypsy Baron’ overture and Ravel’s inexhaustible ‘Bolero’.

The program spotlit, gloriously, the Chicagoans’ chops — the Strauss, Stravinsky, and Ravel advertised its versatility and coloristic skill, the Hindemith its capacity for sheer sonic heft and grandeur. But it also revealed deeper threads. As opera-based works, the Strauss, Hindemith, and Verdi’s overture to ‘Nabucco’ (the evening’s encore), fondly gestured to Muti’s proudest career association, Milan’s La Scala, where his reign (1986-2005) has surpassed all peers.

 

The Stravinsky and Ravel share much more than their year of composition (1928) and enabling impresario (dancer/cultural broker Ida Rubinstein). Both flaunt neoclassical anti-expressiveness, use mechanical repetition as deep structure, and are tours-de-force of orchestration. Given such similarities, why Bolero is programmed far more often? It may lack the Tchaikovsky melodies Stravinsky leaned on (indeed, Ravel quipped, “there’s no music in it”), but thanks to its simplicity, its visceral, inevitable ending, and the good luck to be associated with external cultural phenomena (‘10’ anyone?), it never outwears its welcome or fails to elicit gasps of delight.

 

Bolero even coaxed the only podium animation all evening from Muti, an elegantly stolid old-school batonist. Afterward, he called each of the piece’s soloists – guest principal flute Matthew Roitstein, saxophonist James Romain, etc. – to stand but then conspicuously waded into the ranks to escort principal percussionist Cynthia Yeh for special applause for her virtuosic snare-drumming. (As CSO principal tuba Gene Pokorny nicely described her feat during the pre-concert: “every note you play has to be infinitesimally louder than the previous one — for 18 minutes. Kids, don’t try this at home.”)

The CSO executed both these second-half works with their DNA-deep panache and discipline, but only Bolero felt fun (no fault of theirs). Still, the heart of the Chicagoans’ visit was the Hindemith, not only because it showed off the orchestra’s legendary brass brawn but because it was by far the weightiest and most profound piece on the program. Fully aware that Germany’s fragile 13-year-old democracy was over and a man named Hitler was destined to hold some kind of power, Hindemith nevertheless began composing a long opera about the moral responsibility of the artist to remain independent and true to himself. The Chicago Symphony gave it its props as a twentieth-century pillar.

 

Mark Almond’s unanimous, nobly-toned horns projected with a volume you’d almost swear was amplified (it wasn’t), Timothy Higgins’ trombones gave the horns a run for their money in power and unity, principal oboist William Welter and flautist Roitstein injected the pitch-perfect mournfulness the second-movement Grablegung (Entombment) demands, and the strings lent a tense, motoric edge to St. Anthony’s temptation in the last movement’s opening pages and a sublimely floated calm to his spiritual triumph late in the movement.

 

The sell-out Segerstrom crowd loud-and-clearly relished the visit –  even greeting Muti with huzzahs before he lifted his baton – and left hoping no doubt for a quicker return visit.

Concert photo credits: Todd Rosenberg Photography

Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com